I don't like the fact that I hardly remembered her in the music video, she did nothing memorable and she was kinda blah to me as far as stage presence goes, second would go to Seohyun

that's mean...everyone do their best. so, my ans is NONE of them.

^ just because someone does their best that doesn't mean there isn't a "least" but ok

i know everyone did their best. but if i have to choose, its yuri. she got less lines than other members and in term of dancing, i just see she dance normal like she used too

yuri is pretty forgettable in the video.

i honeslty didn't notice ANYTHING, she was the same in dancing and singing
Yuri and Seohyun would be my second choise

^ i think the song did some justice for her voice

^ yeah of course it did, but her voice ALWAYS sounds like that, imo

^Same here but with me it's Yuri. Her voice is always the same and her dance skills are too. That's just me though. IMO Hyoyeon improved the best! Her dancing has become much better and so has her voice. She stood out more to me than any other of the MV's.

Sunny and taeyeon
and maybe fany too

^do you mind explain tiff and sun to me

well they're good.. but I have to choose yoona... She is my last in terms of voice...

maybe a lot voted for Yuri coz she has a little time appearance in paparrazi... the steps are just basic...

Most of the main singers really didn't improve in singing and like wise the dancers.

I think Yuri. She didn't improve anything imo. Taeyeon too but I picked Yuri because I think Yuri is a bit getting worse