SEO DID GREAT

Jessica is the only one who actually had challenging parts. Seohyun and Tiffany wasn't very interesting and their parts weren't all that difficult like Jessica

Taeyeon. But among these three, Seohyun. Jessica's super high pitch part sounds a little processed (like her part in The Boys). Even in the live performances they let her lipsync this part (because of laziness?)

agree with tiagih!!
both seo n fany did a great job too!!!

@vinxinc r u sure jessica lipsync?? i dnt think so....we all know jessica is lazy especially at dancing but when it comes to singing,she try her best and she donesnt fool around like when she's dancing!!!

^^vinxvinc her part wasn't lipsyched

link

theres still something unreal, fishy about that part. IDK.

Also they look exhausted in that performance. Sooyoung, Yuri and Tiffany's "talking" parts sound horrible :|

^that performance was the closest thing you will find to a clear less backtrack version. It sounds weird because Jessica is nasally like usual

link

She's great!

jessica, i really love her high part at the end..for me she sang perfect in the live performance too
seohyun, she was good too

Jessica perfect song and his high notes were great personally loved

i didn't vote on Jessica, because, aside from her high note, the rest of the lines weren't that spectacular, any member could sing it
i didn't vote on Seohyun either because, while she's great on the studio version, she's not that great on live performances, idk if it's just me, but she sounds awkward

so, my vote goes for Tiffany

tiagih what challenging parts? the high note yes, but what more? Jessica did so much more in "the boys".
and yes she actually lypsynced in some of the performances but every member did the same at some point

^Pa I think you are being a bit bias here.

For one this wasn't a vocally challenging song, Taeyeon did more work in Twinkle so did Seohyun, so its not like this song has a lot of challenging parts as it is. I know you are not talking about challenging parts for a singer when Tiffany is notorious for having backtrack for most of her parts including this song.

Taeyeon, actually

Jessica

Tiffany. Its amazing =D

Jessica of course

imo~ love jessica <3

In live performances totally Fany <3

1. Neo jalnasseo cheongmal! ,
2. Keu namja wahnjeon mame deureonna bwah!
3.Yaegiman haedo eojil haetdanikka?
4.Na Na Na Na Na Na Hey!
5.Don't stop! Lets bring it back to 1:40
6.Eonjena nae gyeoten naepyeoni dwaehjugo kwii giulyeojuneun neo

(Jessica's solo part is only these.. and I chose her because her last solo part which is #7 is her best line among all her lines which is not really hard for her because it's not really a high note and compared to fany and seohyun she has the better lines which as I said is the #7.. BUT as i read others comment I've seen some that sica is the only one who has challenging part.. but what part is that?? )

Her SOLO was BEAST! LOVE SICA<3