For sure.
These three can dance extremely good and with more practice, they can have AMAZING choreographies.
Singing: one good singer and two okayish singers. I'm sure with practice from a vocal coach, they can improve.
The music they would have would be totally different. It could be badass but not like IGAB because these three are the fierce mature looking members. They also have the attitude. I'm sure these three would rock. Also, Sooyoung is very popular. I think Yuri is popular in Korea, and Hyo is popular overseas. They would sell well. As long as they are in snsd, Sones would do anything to make them win!
Like Tippany said they would make a great dancers' subunit! On top of that I like voices of Yuri and Hyoyeon. Sooyoung is a good singer too and has abilities of a leader. She could be one is this group. Besides all the girls here seem to get along really well (SooRi, YulHyo at least) and I like them as a trio <3
altough i love the idea of SHY, i don't think they would be that popular in SK and that's what matters the most, sadly =S cause SM wants money
so i pick Triple S....
it's a perfect idea for a subunit, because they're the next best singers after TTS and their voices compliment well. they're the 3 members with the highest pitched voices and i can already imagine beautiful ballads
plus, Sooyoung and Sunny are more popular than Yuri and Hyoyeon, ever since last year, tbh.
and Jessica well, she's already very popular, so it's always a plus
Someone very close to me was talking about potential subunits and these were the ones that she said were more discusses (mostly SHY).
One thing I like about SHY is that I would expect a great performance and honestly of the two I would have chosen SHY because at least I wouldn't get bored watching them. I am not worried about visuals because honestly Yuri has a strong enough fanbase to attract attention and SM knows how to make thier idols look good for stages and mv, netizens are fickle so I am not so worried about them not getting attention because of thier looks. Although I have been told that Yuri wouldn't fit the group because of how she dances lately, but that could change.
The only flaw this group would have is the same as any other, music. Vocals aren't too much of a problem because some of the best idols can't sing but put on a strong performance. However with that performance comes a great song. I think (just my opinion) people worry too much about vocals like that is the only thing it takes. You need great music to get noticed. SHY are from SNSD so they will get attention automatically, the thing is that the song they are singing has to be something worth listening to.
As far as S3X are concerned my biggest problem is Jessica, and not just because she is lazy dancer but she comes across as weak to me. I remember when she was doing her musical she fainted, the airport incident where she was "knocked out" from hitting a rail but there was no bruise or physical injury, not to mention BLANC. I don't think Jessica would have time or the energy to give the group justice without killing herself or something close to it.
Their voices would be nice and I would love to hear them sing and dance together. However to me they fit more ideally and not realistically. I would want S3X to showcase thier talent to the fullest of thier ability which aside from the music, I think SHY would do better.
The only thing S3X has over the other group is that they are more versatile, meaning the can do cute and edgy, SHY seems more limited to the tougher style than a softer style.
^ Sunny and Sooyoung have growing popularity. Sooyoung as she continues to do well on dramas will get her name out there more, and Sunny going on shows and DJing will get her popular. Not saying Jessica is irrevelant but she isn't as pivital as say Yoona. Unless they make the dance too simple (which would piss me off) to make Jessica not look lazy.
Why dance? They have the 3 best voices for ballads. Their tones are definetely beautiful, and they can match perfectly. With a sensitive and touching ballad they could get great success. Their voices are not the best but they are definetely better than TTS in ballads. Tae's voice is strong, Jessica's too, but Tae can't express fealings. Seohyun can't neither. Not to mention Soo can pull a rap if neccesary.
The only problem I could see is that they are not as popular as TTS, but Jessica is really popular in SK. Sunny and Sooyoung have grown popularity later. Sunny's probably one of the most popular members right know (remember Yuri and Fany dropped, which leave one site in the top 5). Soo is not considered ugly anymore, in a magazine they placed her the 11th most beautiful woman of Korea.
There's no problem with the visual, SK is atracted by Jessice, so she should be. Soo is the best member to lead the sub-unit.
They are also 3 of the most popular members in Europe and America, they could make English version of their album. Japanese too, as Soo and Sica are the most popular members in Japan.
About Shy, I'm not very sure. Hyo and Yuri can sing while they are quiet, but they get breathless while dancing, and Soo can't sing a whole song alone while has a powerful dance. Not to mention Yuri and Hyo are the least popular members in SK.
^ Popularity won't matter because they are from SNSD. Visuals don't matter because all the members from S2X or SHY can look good with the right makeup and shots in the mv. International popularity doesn't matter because they aren't an international group. Yes the group is solid except when it comes to Jessica.
SHY only would have a problem with singing but no one said they has to sing the whole song, they could rap or sing/talk the whole time. Plus all of them can do ballads just not powerful ones like we are used to from the whole group of TTS.
^Popularity matter. Inside and outside the group. That's why TTS had success (and why they are having now with such horrible album), Taemin got success because of being Taemin, and Key hasn't got success because of being Key.
Ask a Korean if they think Yuri and Hyoyeon can be visuals.
There are more markets than SK.
When it comes to Jessica's perform, but she's well-known in SK, and she has a powerful voice.
SooSunSica actually could make better ballads than TTS if they have the chance. Their voices match it better. And they are not generic (you won't find another Sunny/Jessica/Sooyoung voice in other group).
Rapping get Hyoyeon and Yuri even more breathless.
^ if they were a new group like Red Velvet then I would say popularity mattered but they are all from SNSD, no matter what they group will get attention anyway so wither its SHY TTS or S3X, they will be popular because they have popular idols in them. That is why I said popularity doesn't matter because anyone of thier names sells and gets attention.
Singing is nice but its not the biggest thing in the world and also it is relative. If SHY came out, just them singing nicely would impress people because no one expects them to sing that well anyway. S3X would probably be better at the singing portion, but because of Jessica they can't utilize the best performance. SHY would give a better performance because they all have passion and can dance well, S3X on the other hand not so much (as a whole).
Jessica has a unique voice, but power I would have to disagree on.
All of what you are saying make sense but your missing the fact that the only difference between the groups is one group can dance better and one group can sing better. The deciding factor of which is better is dependent on who can put on a better performance and who has the better music (I didn't say singing). Try not to think popularity will mean much because TTS is a group with the popular members however thier Holler song isn't doing as well as twinkle because not many fans are buying the EP (but it may change). That or look at SNSD, with every comeback they don't also do so well why, because the music is not the best.
Don't misunderstand, I would vote for S3X if Jessica wasn't there or showed some promise professionally.
Don't misunderstand me, I already know that Jessica has an horrendous performance, but she sounds exactly like in the studio, same with SooSun. What I'm saying is that they should make a non generic mini-album with slow, sensitive and powerful songs ,that would make you cry or put a sunrise in your face, focused in their voice quality and expression . It could work with the right members (SooSunSica).
When you think in a ballad, which voices come to your mind? For me, Jessica, Sunny and Sooyoung.
I'm not saying that SHY would be bad, but if I could chose, I think SooSunSica would be way more successful.
^again your depending on the music, which isn't a good guarantee. Just because they have great voices that doesn't mean they will have a great song to sing. At with SHY we won't expect them to sing and whatever music they have they can at least make it an entertaining performance.
These three can dance extremely good and with more practice, they can have AMAZING choreographies.
Singing: one good singer and two okayish singers. I'm sure with practice from a vocal coach, they can improve.
The music they would have would be totally different. It could be badass but not like IGAB because these three are the fierce mature looking members. They also have the attitude. I'm sure these three would rock. Also, Sooyoung is very popular. I think Yuri is popular in Korea, and Hyo is popular overseas. They would sell well. As long as they are in snsd, Sones would do anything to make them win!
so i pick Triple S....
it's a perfect idea for a subunit, because they're the next best singers after TTS and their voices compliment well. they're the 3 members with the highest pitched voices and i can already imagine beautiful ballads
plus, Sooyoung and Sunny are more popular than Yuri and Hyoyeon, ever since last year, tbh.
and Jessica well, she's already very popular, so it's always a plus
One thing I like about SHY is that I would expect a great performance and honestly of the two I would have chosen SHY because at least I wouldn't get bored watching them. I am not worried about visuals because honestly Yuri has a strong enough fanbase to attract attention and SM knows how to make thier idols look good for stages and mv, netizens are fickle so I am not so worried about them not getting attention because of thier looks. Although I have been told that Yuri wouldn't fit the group because of how she dances lately, but that could change.
The only flaw this group would have is the same as any other, music. Vocals aren't too much of a problem because some of the best idols can't sing but put on a strong performance. However with that performance comes a great song. I think (just my opinion) people worry too much about vocals like that is the only thing it takes. You need great music to get noticed. SHY are from SNSD so they will get attention automatically, the thing is that the song they are singing has to be something worth listening to.
As far as S3X are concerned my biggest problem is Jessica, and not just because she is lazy dancer but she comes across as weak to me. I remember when she was doing her musical she fainted, the airport incident where she was "knocked out" from hitting a rail but there was no bruise or physical injury, not to mention BLANC. I don't think Jessica would have time or the energy to give the group justice without killing herself or something close to it.
Their voices would be nice and I would love to hear them sing and dance together. However to me they fit more ideally and not realistically. I would want S3X to showcase thier talent to the fullest of thier ability which aside from the music, I think SHY would do better.
The only thing S3X has over the other group is that they are more versatile, meaning the can do cute and edgy, SHY seems more limited to the tougher style than a softer style.
They are great dancets, not to mention Hyo- our Dancing Queen.
Second, they have a comparatively good voice. And also they are beautiful....
SM could invest alot for them coz they are tall. Don't u agree?
They are also quite sexy, compared to S3X.
That's why i choose SHY.
you made some very good points
yeah, tbh, SooSicSu's biggest problem would be Jessica, for all the reasons you mentioned
but let's not forget that she brings the popularity and money
The only problem I could see is that they are not as popular as TTS, but Jessica is really popular in SK. Sunny and Sooyoung have grown popularity later. Sunny's probably one of the most popular members right know (remember Yuri and Fany dropped, which leave one site in the top 5). Soo is not considered ugly anymore, in a magazine they placed her the 11th most beautiful woman of Korea.
There's no problem with the visual, SK is atracted by Jessice, so she should be. Soo is the best member to lead the sub-unit.
They are also 3 of the most popular members in Europe and America, they could make English version of their album. Japanese too, as Soo and Sica are the most popular members in Japan.
About Shy, I'm not very sure. Hyo and Yuri can sing while they are quiet, but they get breathless while dancing, and Soo can't sing a whole song alone while has a powerful dance. Not to mention Yuri and Hyo are the least popular members in SK.
SHY only would have a problem with singing but no one said they has to sing the whole song, they could rap or sing/talk the whole time. Plus all of them can do ballads just not powerful ones like we are used to from the whole group of TTS.
Ask a Korean if they think Yuri and Hyoyeon can be visuals.
There are more markets than SK.
When it comes to Jessica's perform, but she's well-known in SK, and she has a powerful voice.
SooSunSica actually could make better ballads than TTS if they have the chance. Their voices match it better. And they are not generic (you won't find another Sunny/Jessica/Sooyoung voice in other group).
Rapping get Hyoyeon and Yuri even more breathless.
Singing is nice but its not the biggest thing in the world and also it is relative. If SHY came out, just them singing nicely would impress people because no one expects them to sing that well anyway. S3X would probably be better at the singing portion, but because of Jessica they can't utilize the best performance. SHY would give a better performance because they all have passion and can dance well, S3X on the other hand not so much (as a whole).
Jessica has a unique voice, but power I would have to disagree on.
All of what you are saying make sense but your missing the fact that the only difference between the groups is one group can dance better and one group can sing better. The deciding factor of which is better is dependent on who can put on a better performance and who has the better music (I didn't say singing). Try not to think popularity will mean much because TTS is a group with the popular members however thier Holler song isn't doing as well as twinkle because not many fans are buying the EP (but it may change). That or look at SNSD, with every comeback they don't also do so well why, because the music is not the best.
Don't misunderstand, I would vote for S3X if Jessica wasn't there or showed some promise professionally.
When you think in a ballad, which voices come to your mind? For me, Jessica, Sunny and Sooyoung.
I'm not saying that SHY would be bad, but if I could chose, I think SooSunSica would be way more successful.
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment