These three were absolute worst.
Sunny and Tiffany were very nasal. But Yuri's covering of Jessica's line in ITNW left me cringe.

agree with amysakurada

I don't think these three were the worst, Sooyoung should have been added since her voice was kinda all over the place as far as pitch goes. Also don't think its fair to be so harsh on the people that sang the most.

Tiffany by far was the worst, Yuri never cracked, Sunny is a work in progress but was okay, but Tiffany every other song I think she just wanted to shout her parts and she cracked or went flat on many of them.

^ in what songs did Sooyoung go off pitch? I thought she did well at least in all the ones I've seen (Gee, Flower Power, ITNW, Divine, Love and Girls, Galaxy Supernova,...)

I felt bad for laughing when Tiffany covered Jessica's part in Divine. No wonder they didn't give her the lines originally.

I am sorry, Fany-ah, but you're cover of Jessica's line is just...

Part of Jessica in Divine was the worst I've heard

I think Yuri covered well. Sunny, Tiffany and Yoona the worst for me.

^I agree on Sunny and Tiffany being the worst but not Yoona loved her part in Divine and she covered Sica's part pretty well considering her voice isn't nearly as high, most people actually think she (as well as others) covered her voice pretty well

Amy,
The reason I said she needed to be up there (and I would argue more than Yuri) because most of her parts were recorded and the parts she did weren't better than Yuri.

Notable was My Oh My

^ hmm interesting. I think Spoyoung's covering of Jessica's part in Gee was pretty good though.

^^I disagree, she sounded forced even if her parts weren't challenging.

Yoona should be on the list too. i still don't understand why she covers most of Sica's lines now. smh

anyway, Fany. sorry Fany you know i like you but you sounded awful


Sunny sounded bad too


i didn't hear much Yuri so i can't judge

uh? Sooyoung? sones in general said she was one of the best and that her voice improved very much
and i agree =O

Tiffany

...

Amy I am not saying Sooyoung is bad, but the list could have been a bit more length in my opinion
Taeyeon and Seohyun were the best

Soo Yul and Sunny are in the middle

Yoona






Tiffany


PA, Sooyoung didn't that much I mean most of her parts were recorded, so its hard saying she sounded great if she didn't that much. I would never say she hasn't improved singing but I wouldn't base it off the dome but with that being said I am not saying she was the worst.


Dani
In Divine her voice wasn't forced at all but yes something parts I could hear the squeezing. But again I give credit where it is due, it wasn't bad considering.

It was bad, but I would take the fact that she was crying like crazy into consideration for her awful singing.

Yoona was better than Yuri.

^ idk nothing Yoona did tops Yuri in ITNW

Lol when i listen to yuri in Tokyo dome this gave me huge hope that yul may back her top as singer she improved a lot

I keep wondering why they keep giving line and especially in divine I have a feeling the seohyun would've done a lot better yonma did supposedly good at covering jessica lines in divine. That concert should prove to sm to STOP giving all of the lines to tiffany I know she sorta improve but not that much she sound the same in genie era at least seohyum and sunny sound different but tiffany I used really like her voice but since hear lile ever 5 second I really hate it no hate please but it the truth

Tiffany