The first group did a perfect job in the Tokyo Dome, the second one an horrible one except some covers from Sunny.

Taeyeon is in the middle and I think she got the right parts.

I lost all hope for Hyoyeon, 1 cover in more than an hour of concert.

ofc, why not, but I don't really care, because I like it the way it is, I loved their performances

They did well in Tokyo Dome, but I hated the High parts of Tiffany (which were parts of Jessica) mainly Divine, also I annoyed that having so many lines in indestructible, give even more lines (parts of Jessica), when they could give it the other, as to Yoona did more or less, but I would have liked to give more lines to Seohyun and Yuri

But what's done is already done, just wanted to vent than I thought

i still don't freakin' understand why Yoona covers most of Sica's lines

first of all, you have the most basic reason: Yoona is a SUB vocal and the WORST snsd singer. Sica was a MAIN vocal and far better than Yoona



second but no less important....she sounded BAD. just....BAD. she was out of tune so many times. good fucking lord.
the only time she actually sounded good was in "Karma butterfly"



seriously, is the producer Yoona biased?

seriously, why so angry, it doesn't sound terrible, Yoona should get more lines at least in their concerts, too, since she has mostly 2 lines in a song, and Hyo, Yul, too, they at least was noticeable now, in concerts fans don't come only to listen to TaeTiSeo, they want all of them, so let it be, it's not some kind of music show or award ceremony, besides in concerts I don't think people care that much how they sing, they comes to have fun and see them in real, well ofc singing is important, but trust me, they don't mind sub-vocals singing much, I would be happy to see Yoona singing alone all their songs if I could...

No

^^Have we heard the same concert? Really, the only time she did well was when she sang a Jessica part in Paparazzi (I think before the first chorus)

Edit: She did her own lines well, they all did, but she didn't with Jessica's lines.

Dani are you talking with me?

Yuri and Seo didn't do well either. Only Sooyoung's cover in Gee was good.

^^yep

I'm not saying they must do well, I'm saying it's okay that they have more lines in their own concerts, because they're more noticeable to fans and (saying the same again) that fans want to see them singing all, not only TTS

oh my God, my head will burst hahaha, do you guys really don't understand what I want to say?^^ You only care about those lines.....does it hurts you all so much? omg they are group 7 years and can't even sing more? omg omg I'm really speechless... even, probably, no one in their concert care about that, because they're coming to enjoy it

First it's bad that TTS is singing so much, now that Yoona...who's next?

Seohyun, Yuri, Taeyeon were the only ones that sounded really nice the whole concert through

Sunny did okay and Yoona didn't make too many mistakes which is good considering she sang live most of the time for her covers. Sooyoung didn't sing live most of her parts so I think we need to take that into consideration. She sounded nice in some parts but its no like she sang all that much.


I find it funny when Sooyoung got more lines for thier japanese songs no one mentions that just because she can speak the language doesn't mean she needs more singing parts when there are better singers. But hey she got what she wanted. Yoona wants to work on her vocals and get more of Jessica's covers for the japanese covers and people are whining, as if she can't get more lines. Its not like she butchered her lines. She is no main vocalist but she sang LIVE most of her covers and made very few mistakes, like cracking or going off pitch....she was just really quiet sometimes.

I like when Taeyeon and Tippany cover sica's parts
Especially when fany covered "we are always one" in divine @ tokyo dome <3
It was beautiful

Yuri and Seo didn't do well either. Only Sooyoung's and yoona's cover in Gee was good

Gretulee you're missing my point. she sang her own lines pretty well. but she sounded really bad covering Sica's lines. let's be honest here, most of the Sica lines she covered, were hard to sing. the one in My oh My, for example. it was very high pitched and Yoona couldn't even reach the higher part. it was painful to hear, imo.

the problem here is that the producer gave Yoona lines that she can't even sing properly. it looked more line he gave Yoona all those Sica lines, for pity

another thing that bothers me is how she got so many lines to cover, even though she already had many lines in that respective song
All my love is for you- she already had 3 lines in that song, SooHyo had 2. yet, they gave Yoona a Sica line and she ended up being with 4. how does that make sense???????????
another one would be "divine". WHY SO MANY PARTS, when she already had quite a few? why did she sing the last "we can be divine" ??

Galaxy supernova: really? they gave the english part to Yoona, even though she sucks at english?

love & girls: they gave her a Sica line that is once again very high pitched and Yoona sounded really bad



and there's many, MANY more but i can't remember right now

^At least in Galaxy Supernova, it's not fair saying she didn't do well, she didn't have a bad pronunciation.

And I don't think the second point is right, since the part is covered well, since it's not the case. I don't mind, for example, Sunny or Tiffany covering in a song in which they already got many parts, if they do well, again, not the case.

Could you honestly tell me why you're making such a big drama of it?

I don't really care with whoever sings Sica's lines tbvh. Although I'm not distraught over the fact that Jessica left, I will say that no one can replace her voice, so granted, whoever covers them won't sound as good, so I don't really care who does it.

IKR! She had the most unique voice, I miss it

I don't see how Yuri was good at Dome. Her voice was lame as usual.

Tiagih like other members, Sooyoung sang all of her lines live too. You can hear her go off pitched a few times.

Yoona did a great job. And Japan loves her the most so it makes sense they have her all the extra lines.

^ No she didn't.
Chain Reaction-not live
Mr Mr- not live
Animal/hoot-not live
indestructible- not live...or heavily recorded backtrack
divine- live
mr taxi- not live
galaxy supernova- not live
bad girl-not live
TOP/the boys- not live
RDR- not live
MOM- live
ITNW- live
Karma Butterfly- not live
Genie (my fave part)- not live but prerecorded
I can go on



i don't think the love of Japan is the reason she got the extra lines, I mean they liked her before right? But maybe you are right

YoonA's voice had improved a lot ! I really agreed to the producer to GIVE jESSICA'S line to YoonA.Its perfect! YoonA improved a lot ! Now,SONE know that YoonA is a vocalist too. FUCK YOU HATERS !!!

Yoonsoofany kinda ruined it with covering Jessica's part and makes her fans miss her even more sooo I think I give this one to sooyulseo.

@snsdfans1: woah chill there gurl. We like all know Yoona is the weakest singer and shes a lead dancer (4-2 depending on people's opinions) and shes a lead singer. It only makes sense that she doesnt get jessica's lines because Jessica is a main singer. therefore, she might not be able to handle the lines.

But i agree. Sooyoung is the most improved member in 2014, Seohyun is a main vocal is seems like, and Yuri got worse. However, in the Tokyo Dome performances ive seen, she did amazing for getting worse this year. also in the last year performances she did pretty good vocally covering Jessica and her own lines so i think she'll get better with Jessica gone. i dont know why though :P

No one can replace Jessica's voice so the song won't be the same. But it would be as good if the producer gives the lines to a respective tone to a certain song.

Jessica's voice is well-known to be high-pitched, so lines with that relative pitch should be given to either Sunny or Sooyoung.
For lines with low tone, give them to Yoona, Yuri, Seohyun, Tiffany or Hyoyeon
For lines that require high notes, give them to Taeyeon

agree with @pearlxashxdawn. no one can ever place Jessica's voice.

Yoona did a good job in covering Jessica's part. it's not like she sang the ad-libs or high note. for me, it was quite okay.

But yeah, I don't like Tiffany's voice for high note.. she did bad... really, they should give the lines to Sunny or Seohyun. But considering that Seohyun was busy with her musical, misses their rehearsal and had no time to practice... IDK.. tiffany was really bad.. not all songs but most of the times.. she really didn't suit high notes... really...

i think in the japanese song sooyoung and seohyun should cover sica lines since they actually speak the lanuage and have great pronunciation unlike tiffany and yoona who happen to be the worst speaker
and seohyun and sooyoung are really good and somewhat similar to sica unlike tiffany who just ruined the whole song like she did divine