Good point! I've seen lots of spots that have changed their icons more than once, but this one has years! I really like it actually, but it's time for a new one :D

I've got a few... I'll post them in different replies if you don't mind :)

1.

Don't mind at all! :) KEEP EM COMIN!

OK!

2.

Numbers 3 and 4 are a little similar

3.

And #4

Hope I was useful :D

I hope the creator reads this so that she'll change the icon! I'm just someone who wanted to change the icon, I don't have the authority to do so, but hopefully he/she will read this!! Oh &&& the second one is my fave! :)

Cool!

I have one!

hmmm... lets see what i have :) hehe.

Hmmmm........ I like the one it is currently so I wouldn't mind it to stay that way but here is an idea...

Another.... hmmmm.... here......

lol

I like the Dice idea but i prefer color. so here...

I like this! :)

:) dolphin :)

water

I like this one.

Its like a rave...

I like this one as well. :)

Sure...

Jonapello23 hasn't been on in a while. I just hope he comes back soon!!! :)

how bout....

holy effin shizz! i didn't think i'd get this many responses to this thing. i got a question tho, does anyone know the creator of the random spot? that way i can contact her/him with this info. :) thank you, very appreciated of the pics.
LuvWeezy; is this Jonapello23 the creator? do you know how to contact him?

wow. all of your guys suggestions are awesome! :) Hopefully we can change the icon!
LuvWeezy; yours are like, my fave, just saying :)
KishuandIchigo; thats cool to :)
all of them are fantastic...

Here's another!

And another!

And another!

:)

This one is suppose to move!

:D

XD

breebree; I like the last one the most :) thanks for responding!

Here are my icon sugestions:

1.

2.

Thanks CullenProperty!
I really like the first one I posted above, though. The colorful one! I think it would go along with the banner really well!
And I really like your flower myau!

one more:

No prob, BreeBree! Love it Myau

Jonapello23 is the creator. It's too bad he barely comes on. My suggestion is contacting Fanpop. If you scroll all the way down you'll see how. 'contact us' is what you'd click, but maybe just saying "Omg the icon for the random spot is OLD! Can't we change it?!?!" would be pushy and wouldn't get our point across. So what if we created a forum where all fanpoppers who wanted the icon changed, would simply reply by writing their user names, like a petition. And then when we contact fanpop, give them the link and say "See, look at all of us fanpoppers who agree that the random spot, one of the most popular spot's multiple-years-old-icon desperately needs a change! Please!" I have some suggestions.
>> link
>> link

Oh && these are cool.
>> link
>> link
>>link
>>link
>> link

:)

:D

I like the one we have now but I'm open to change.

Bunnies.

Icon.