Remember this is a comment based pick

Jessica is a really good dancer she's just lazy. The other three have obvious problems with dancing, Sica's only issue with dancing is that she dosen't try. She still looks pretty good when dancing though.

link

I think she could have been fourth best dancer behind Hyoyeon, Yuri, and Yoona if she worked harder in dancing. But she didn't work hard so Sooyoung and Seohyun became better and Sica is now sixth in dancing. She's still better than the last three though.

^ just asking if she is lazy how is she a good dancer?
Edit: she looks really young in that clip, does she still dance like that presently?

Ok from here on out, I would like to see clips or videos no OLDER than 2 years, I would like to be fair in my analysis but can I be if people show me clips of a person that is really old.

Jessica was then a really great dancer but if she work a litter a harder and not be lazy she would be prefect.
link - jessica from 0.00 to 0.34
jessica's dance move was really powerful.

^ i said clip s and video no OLDER then 2 years I now know what they look at each concept and this was during their debut

Hello... thry to watch this vid...
link - Tiffany and taeyeon with Sooyoung & Seohyun - womanizer -------- Jessica and Sunny with Yuri and Yoona - Hollaback girl

link - It's sunny and Jessica

to be fair.. these vids are hoot fancams on May 11, 2011

Jessica - link

Taeyeon - link

Sunny - link

Tiffany - link

Hope these helps... ^____^

^it does can I ask why you chose Jessica?

well...Honestly I find it hard to choose from Jess, Taeyeon and sunny... I don't have any biases in them but base on what I see in many MVs.. I find Jessica better than the 3... for me she's just consistent.
taeyeon - sometimes I find her weak in dancing in some MV's like the boys and paparazzi but sometimes she's good
Sunny - same with taeyeon, sometimes good sometimes not..
Tiffany - she's really the least when it comes to dancing. [it's a fact] but not really bad though.....
It's just an opinion.. ^___^

Oh come on Sunny is way better her moves are powerful and pretty fluid, but I can say she came from a long line of have mistakes on stage but she still loved nice

link:link


Now Jessica is lazy, talented but lazy if you watch their paparazzi music video she things half asses there look at 1:19
link:link

it really boils down to what is more important more effort into your work or doing the choreography, Sunny gives a good performance most of the time but can see some mistakes in choreography, Jessica does the choreography fine but she doesnt push in the dances but that could also be cause she has to sing. If you notice most of the really good singer don't dance really hard just like most of the really good dancers can't sing all that well. But still Sunny is better since she can show off her skill in dancing and doesn't have to worry much about having to sound nice in singing since she isn't a main singer

Well it's your opinion, I respect that... I have my opinion too... ^___^

^ i meant no disrespect, i was more about the polls

SugarBell 20, I like that you made a comparison, this winner of this poll will not be easy based on the commetns. I really can't tell who will win, DOES ANYONE MIND A TIE because this and the "singer" poll are really hard to try and figure out who does better based on videos

Jessica is a lazy dancer, but even so her natural talent is enough to make her better than the bottom three, to answer your question. I wouldn't say she's a good dancer anymore just better than Sunny, Taeyeon, and Fany.
link Sorry I couldn't find a better one for some reason it's hard to find clips of the singers dancing. Anyways when it focuses on Sunny she seems a bit lost but Sica is sharp and keeping up well.

As for the tie thing, I think you should just pick one instead of having two tie. Most people are saying Jessica here and she's winning the poll too. As for the singers, I think Yuri, Sooyoung, and Yoona are pretty close in skill but most people commenting picked Yuri, I think and she's also winning the poll. Who knows maybe more people will post videos up later.

^ Thank you for commenting but here is my dilemma.
Jessica may have all this talent right but 1.)She doesn't look like she gives much into her dance (based on the Paparazzi video) and she even looks like she is not dancing to her full potential (based on hoot video). It is one thing to have talent but it seems like she doesn't commit fully to even doing the dance properly. I don't care if she is a lazy dancer so long as she executes properly when it counts. I know it is not fair that their are no recent (no older than 2 years) videos of Jessica, but this IS comment based, and Sunny's videos are "stronger" then Jessica's

Though I would put my vote "easier" on Sunny based on how sharp and clean her dances are (based on The Boys), I will be honest her videos show a better "quality" of dance, my only problem is I have to take into consideration if Jessica dances the way she does because she sings more then Sunny when she needs all her energy into singing more then dancing thus she dances so "less enthusiastic". If Sunny dances more often then Jessica then it would obviously look like she is a better dancer, but that doesn't seem fair.

I am still asking people in my household and friends to help me analyze this videos because that is where is boils down to.
If I choose:
Jessica,she wins because she has to sing more than Sunny so it makes sense she doesn't dance as hard as others
Sunny, she wins because in performances she has a better "quality" of dances then everyone on the list

This is why i would rather call it a tie, no wonder tiagih asked me to do this because this particular round is very difficult because you are working with extremes.