Josh here. I have been wondering since this is a large group of people is there anyone who is just "extra". I mean they all can sing and dance but is there anything else these girls can do besides that, if not who can't. I want to know which member is the most useless (doesn't add anything special to the group) to the most useful (add alot to the group). Explain why and not just for the one you voted for but for ALL of them.

Only ONE person can have thier vote counted for the winner of each round. So in order to have your vote count you have the best or most convincing comment, which included videos or famous saying. NO links older then 1 year are counted.The best explanation gets their vote counted, so have fun

FYI, this is for FUN, so no swearing at one another but debating is fine. If you want you can place a comment on who you think had the best comment.

ok like all member and i cant see snsd without any member
but hyo hyo is one of great dancer in kpop but i cant see that in mvs she always back but in some mvs she did solo dance but she didnt get big chance in any mv right ? she didnt make her useless but sm make her like that but she is not her fault but 4 me sm did that even with yuri when i saw paparazzi i said why they did that to yuri i cant see yuri a lot in mv like hyo too and that make me feel so bad coz many ppl think she become useless but it is sm fault i sometimes hate this company

okay, why is seohyun? i bet no one will vote for TTS member since they are the only members who promote the name of SNSD this year through songs....

" Explain why and not just for the one you voted for but for ALL of them.

Only ONE person can have thier vote counted for the winner of each round. So in order to have your vote count you have the best or most convincing comment, which included videos or famous saying."

princess89 agree with u seohyun is useful just like tae ithink yoona and sooyoung no need to explain

^Josh: you have to explain in order for your vote to count.

OK I WILL EXPLAIN WHY I didnt choose the rest
like princess said TTS made great job this year by sub unit
yoona yuri soo dancers of group even hyo dancer but they appear more than her so sorry
yoona the face
sunny ok i think she may be next
this reasons not who can sing or dance who make mv look great

4 video i didnt have to post links watch all mvs u can see even hyo the best dancer but snsd dance in mv cant fit her

can i ask u something so only comments wll be count ? not the poll result it is good move coz some ppl just choose coz they hate
btw hyo not my least she is 7th
but i really want to know yr choose i really like yr explain can u too choose and tell us why?

^Josh: tiagih told me people spam here a lot so i decided to be creative. Only the best comment gets their voted picked as the winner of the round. The only way they can be a winner if by giving a good comment which includes a video/ or a good explanation of why the person they voted for and why not everyone else.

I don't want my opinion to influence anyone since I am still fairly new to liking SNSD. I am still getting familiar with certain things

I would base this poll on my assessment of their dancing and singing:
Dancing:
1. Hyoyeon: 92
2. Sooyoung: 87 (I put her second cause I think her dancing suits the style of SNSD the most and she shows the best progress)
3. Yuri: 86 (she has gone downhill a lot and made many mistakes, so 3 points down 89-3=86)
4. Yoona: 84 (she should have better expression while dancing)
5. Sunny: 75
6. Seohyun: 74
7. Jessica: 72
8. Taeyeon: 70
9: Tiffany: 68

Singing:
1. Taeyeon: 94
2. Jessica: 84
3. Tiffany: 82
4. Seohyun: 80
5. Sunny: 79
6. Sooyoung: 66
7. Yuri: 63
8. Hyoyeon: 56
9. Yoona: 55

overall:
1. Taeyeon: 164
2. Jessica: 156
3. Sunny: 154
3. Seohyun: 154
5. Sooyoung: 153
6. Tiffany: 150
7. Yuri: 149
8. Hyoyeon: 148
9. Yoona: 139 + 5 (for being the face of the group) = 144

^this isn't based on singing and dancing because we have already established that they all "can" sing and dance, but I like what you wrote. :D

ithink yoona is the answer

but we have aproblam she is the face of the group

but dont u think 13 days is long time?

^ I am giving this two weeks so that people can have a chance to be give a good comment without having to rush. I may shorten it to a week if there are enough comments to chose a winner, but this is just so people have time to make their answers.

^^You have to be descriptive for your answer to win the round which include why Sooyoung and not everyone else and a video.

no offense, but why are people choosing Seohyun? are they serious?

and i already explained why Yoona is useless. she may be a good dancer, but definitely not the best. she's the worst singer. and then, she's the visual, yes, but that's not a valid argument since most of the europeans and americans don't consider Yoona that pretty. all of my best friends(including guys) said she was so uninteresting. some of them actually said she was ugly. so yeah...
and of course i'm not speaking of EVERY european and american ok? i get it. but in general, this is how it works

^You have to be descriptive for your answer to win the round which include why Yoona and not everyone else and a video.

If the word ANTI wasn't there...

this is a music group, being "useless" means you can't sing or dance well. So someone with the lowest combined score is the answer :D

^they are an "idol" group the last time I looked them up. Being an "idol" I am told goes beyond being able to sing and dance, that is why i asked " I mean they all can sing and dance but is there anything else these girls can do besides that, if not who can't. I want to know which member is the most useless (doesn't add anything special to the group) to the most useful (add alot to the group)."

I liked your comment don't get me wrong but I was looking more to see if anyone adds "less" to the group outside of the realm of singing and dancing.

yeah but even when I added 5 points for Yoona for her "contribution" to the group as the face, she's still the most useless.

Taeyeon-extremely good voice, ok dancer.
Jessica-even though i don't like her voice, she has more experience than some of the members. but her dancing is kinda bad
Tiffany-also a great singer...as for the dancing, i don't understand when people say she's the worst, cause i don't see any difference between her, Jessica, Taeyeon and Sunny
Sunny-she's my next choise after Yoona... the reason i choose her over Yoona, is because she's indeed a better singer
Seohyun-really good voice and her dancing is quite good. why are people voting on her? o_O
Sooyoung-good voice and really good dancing
Yuri-both of her dancing and singing are getting worse, but she still is a really great dancer. the singing could be a little better
Hyoyeon-even though she's not an amazing singer, she still has an interesting voice and she shows more emotion than Yoona. Yoona seems dead when she's singing

as i said before, Yoona is a good dancer, but the fact that there are three members better than her, doesn't help. not only she's "dead" when she's singing, she's also dead when she's dancing. i don't feel anything. she doesn't stand out

look at this video. Hyoyeon is showing the fierceness, Yuri is showing the sexiness and Sooyoung is showing the charisma. i honestly just see Yoona trying to look pretty
link

for the singing...well, if someone finds a recent radio performance that shows big evidence, please post here. this one is old, but seriously, if Yoona was already the worst on this one, i doubt that she improoved a lot now
link
(her singing part in the chorus is just bad. so out of tune)

^dear me its her and Yuri, Tiffany. OMG they all were out of tune

even Sunny said Yonna's role in SNSD is just to be pretty

link

(0:12)

no one is useless
But least talented: Yoona and Hyoyeon

Oh I will be like Tiagih and go into detail

Taeyeon- best singer

Jessica- she is pretty, models, and can sing well

Sunny- she being more popular outside of SNSD then in it, brings more attention to the group without having to sing and dance

Tiffany: ehh she can at least sing well but her dancing such

Hyoyeon- she dance well and her appearances on variety shows helps helps bring press to the group

Yuri- not the best singer and lately a sucky dancer, she should go and let Sooyoung or Yoona take her place. She doesn't add much to SNSD that no one else couldn't add plus she is only popular because she is pretty.
dance:link
sing:link

Sooyoung- she is a well rounded character she is more use then useless sometimes

Yoona- her acting, commercials, and photo shoots beings lots of press to the group, she really can't go to far even if she can't sing all that well

Seohyun- she has a great voice, can dance, and a good role model

@tiagih well yeah, but since Yuri is a better dancer and Tiffany is a better singer, i think it's explained

^Josh:Not really, the link you showed that was supposed to show how bad her singing was but also showed me how bad the others singing was.
I am not saying Yoona is useful or less but the fact of the matter is that in your argument in particular you said "her singing part in the chorus is just bad. so out of tune" well so was Tiffany and Yuri so your argument while may be for Yoona exposed the flaw in the others as well. Which in turn can reveal a "useless" factor about them too, just wanted you to be aware.

But again like I told vinxinc, they are an idol group we already know they can sing and dance. I asked "which member is the most useless (doesn't add anything special to the group) to the most useful (add alot to the group)." this excludes singing and dancing because we already know who sings and dances better and worse but that doesn't make them useless.

Waaaaahhh.... I'm so tired of seeing polls like these. It brings negativity to SNSD fans... it makes fans fight to each other for they should fight for their biases... SNSD is never be famous as of now if one of them is useless.. Everyone of them contributes a lot... by doing MCs, Dramas, CFs, Modelling, etc... Making one of them useless its like you're telling them that she doesn't deserve to be in SNSD.... Don't get me wrong,, it's only my view... because it really hurts me to find some negative comments on my bias... Can we just make polls that cannot harm members???... These kind of polls help gain more ANTIS... It's a Girls' generation fanpage right?? Why make useless polls like these?? Who agrees with me????... I'm sorry *tiagih for saying all of these.. I'm just sad seeing all those comments... T_T

^Tiagih: I know this poll is not orthodox, but I didn't see much harm in it to be honest. There is nothing wrong with constructive criticism and that is all I see here. SNSD aren't perfect and its within reason to point out their flaws, Antis will always be there are there will be more because SONES don't know how to give or make constructive criticism about SNSD let alone their bias.

Don't get me wrong, all who participate in Josh's poll (who will have his own account after this countdown) should know that everyone makes up SNSD not just one person, but its not all bad thing to point out flaws because its obvious they have them and they aren't perfect.

why yuri and yoona? I think they all work hard and Snsd would not be the same without any of them.

@blackpearlyul21 u say this poll isnt good and its makes more anti and its wrong so why u choosed when u say that thing ushouldnt choose any one am iright ??? u choosed seohyun wrong so wrong u even didnt explain why why why why ????? she is the best singer after taeyeon and she is good at dsanceing she is beautiful so what is the the bad thing she bring to snsd plz answer she the best one

Josh: I will end this poll by next Sunday, the winner is between Vinxinc/Pretty_angel92-yoona and Sugarbell20-Yuri. If you you want to be included in the final decision post better comments like these guys, if not I will decide who explained their point best and their choice will win this round.

^ Josh: please read top comment on how you can get your vote to count.

@shiraz97...I"m sorry I didn't choose any.. I like Seohyun... I'm shocked when I saw this... Maybe I accidentally pressed Seohyun.. I Haven't chose any.. I swear..

seohyun is not useless.

What the hell! it could be hyo or yoona

Winner of Round:Vinxinc
Vote goes to:Yoona