I might change the title since the song isn't all that I want you to focus on.

Take into account the three major factors that I want your choice to be based on:

-The Song (obviously)
-Live Performances
-Concept (like whether or not it fits the group)

The valid comments rule will be like my last poll, so just keep commenting.

My Opinion: Dancing Queen or Mr. Mr. but the girls in my opinion fit the concept of Mr. Mr. more than Dancing Queen.

ofc this....Live performances were a mess, their voices don't fit this song at all, song isn't that good, too. I hope Genie will win. Mr.Mr. would be my second choise.

Both the song and concept were a disappointment to me. It has a very "heavy" atmosphere in my opinon. Although this concept fitted GG somehow (like The Boys, Run Devil Run).
What I liked about the song were Jessica's and Yuri's rap, Taeyeon's, Seohyun's and Jessica's lines and Tiffany's high pitch.
Live perfomances were ok.

It's a matter of preference right? I'm not feeling this. Maybe I'm not just a fan of the song although their live perfs were good.

^It's mainly about preference, but I added the other factors just for you to back up your opinion without having to search how sales were and commercial success, and all that other stuff.

I like ITNW but they were too unexperienced, their live wasn't really good. Dancing Queen and Mr Mr come in a close second.

The hype for this song was real but all we got was a bland one. The concept was dark but the song was not and frankly I can't remember the song even after I tried to like it and listened to it non stop. The video was okay but we all know that they had difficulties with that. At the end of the day I regret buying it because all it did was take up space in my phone and when I deleted it I realized that the only song I could remember was the remake one. I then deleted it and I didn't even feel bad. Moral of the story is, never buy and album without listening to a few of the songs first.

^The album isn't that bad, but it has many fillers

Also at some performances they looked like they did not want to be there.

Fillers are bad

The lyrics of Mr. Mr. were cheesy and the song isn't even all that special. The live performances were good, but because of the autotunes in the song there were backtracks helping in the background. And the concept did fit the girls though I would find it more better if they weren't in suits or the fact that they weren't trying to look serious during the performances. While in Dancing Queen everything was good, except for the live.

^Do you really think that the live was good?

this was never an official release, tbh

besides, it's just a remake

I think that their voices don't fit this song

@pretty_angel92 well, they still released this in 2012, and would've been promoting this if IGAB didn't come out a week later.

Current Results:
Mr. Mr./Dancing Queen- 3 comments each
Into the New World/Girls' Generation- 1 comment each

If this ever turns into a tie, I'll make a tiebreaker poll to decide which is first and second.
Keep commenting!

The lives were horrible tbh
I liked the song and thought It kind of fitted this but not all the members
The concept was okay
But the main reason why this was the weakest is because of the lives and it didn't showcase anything. The singing was okay and it didn't show any of the girls clear ability to hit high notes and the dancing was okay. Nothing to spectacular

Woah! ITNW was their debut song, get many attention to them and performances were good. Their dance was so powerfull and tiring, can't believe this song won't be in top 5...Girls' Generation is a really good song, too! Love them. Hope those songs will stay longer haha