Lost is its just me or do kate love both of Jack and Sawyer, season 1-4?

This question is now closed
34 fans picked:
She have always loved just Jack
She have always loved just Jack
   44%
You not alone
You not alone
   38%
She loved Sawyer the most
She loved Sawyer the most
   15%
dont care
dont care
   3%
No
no votes yet
 Lackson4ever85 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

6 comments

user photo
She have always loved just...
clm-anomaly picked She have always loved just Jack:
She obviously felt something for him, but love? No.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
She loved Sawyer the most
pitseleh94 picked She loved Sawyer the most:
Damon: “How much clearer could you be about her choice? I mean, who’s watching it and going, ‘I’m not sure that she picked Sawyer, I think maybe she went with Jack there.’"

Damon: “Yes or No: Does Kate--”
Carlton: "-Yes."
Damon: "-love Sawyer? Well, there you go."
Carlton: "I didn’t even have to hear the whole question; I knew it was a yes."

Damon: "And we later realize Kate is still emotionally reeling from Sawyer’s decision to jump off of the helicopter. This man that she really loves left her, abandoned her, decided to stay behind on the island. She’s trying to heal the emotional scar left by Sawyer taking himself out of the equation.”
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
She have always loved just...
backtoblack picked She have always loved just Jack:
^you don't wana start the quotes thing.lol
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
She have always loved just...
sk91 picked She have always loved just Jack:
OK. Let's do that ones again. I love playing with quotes and I'm in mood so.. ;p

ARGUMENT OF ALL ARGUMENTS. NOT INVALID!
"I l o v e you"
We heard it only ones from her. Who was that she said it to? Oh yeah.. not Sawyer.
Who did she agree to marry? Yeah.. not Saywer.
With who did she actually WANTED to live, share life and so called play house? Yeah.. not Sawyer.
For who did she crashed planes, blowed up Island and.. always came back? Yeah.. not Sawyer.
Who's name she screamed the most during series? ... yeah, I think you catch the drill.

What else did she say during all seasons toward Jack?
I have always been with you
If you weren't here Jack
It was not all misery
I'm glad you are here
I missed you SO much
You haven't ruined anything . Nothing is irreversible
BECAUSE WE CAN'T LEAVE JACK BEHIND


Damon: Jack is the guy she should be with. She does genuinely love him. And she knows that he would take excellent care of her."

Evangeline: I also see her bond with Jack is actually stronger than the bond with Aaron, even though it doesn`t appear to be that way right now. I feel watching Jack deteriorate and reach his low - pushing her away and then her pushing him away - I like that will bring her to her knees. It will be her bond with Jack.

Evangeline: She`s trying to pull away from Sawyer because she recognizes that she loves Jack. I think I spent that walk back thinking that I have to push Sawyer away. I have to. It`s not fair ro him or me or Jack, because I feel too much for Jack to allow this 'thing' with Sawyer to keep going.

Evangeline: So no matter what she is doing with Sawyer, I think Jack still holds the role as the man in her life, even if she is resigned that it will never happen.

Evangeline: Kate couldn't make the choice to take that risk if it weren't for the fact that she has never been able to help herself be madly in love with Jack. It's that awful thing that so many people experience of, "I can't help myself. When he looks me in the eye and he says I need you to support me, THAT'S IT


And bonus because this is truly best quote ever said by producer about any couple. (do I have to add it's only JJ quote about Lost couples?)

You could put Jack and Kate on a New York City street and have them pass each other and rush hour on a Wednesday morning. And they would stop and turn, slowing to watch each other go by. They know each other within the context, of a universal recognition. They have met before this life, and they will meet again in another.

- JJ FUCKING ABRAMS. mastermind.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
You not alone
carambolas picked You not alone:
I think she loved both
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
You not alone
DR76 picked You not alone:
She probably loved both of them . . . but not equally. I think she loved Jack a lot more than Sawyer. She had a bad habit of using Sawyer as an emotional crutch, whenever she thought that her relationship with Jack was in jeopardy. I can recall a scene from early Season 3 in which after sleeping with Sawyer in a previous episode, she was talking with Jack over a walkie-talkie and was practically in tears over the idea of leaving him behind. Sawyer was observing her . . . and I began to wonder if he suspected that she loved Jack more.

I always found it odd that she was supposed to take Aaron as an emotional crutch over Sawyer jumping from the helicopter. Yet, after the end of her engagement with Jack, she had a photograph of him, her and Aaron on her living room mantlepiece. At least I think so. I could be wrong. She slept with Sawyer during late Season 3, while harboring jealousy over Jack's friendship with Juliet. She was more concerned about Jack, immediately after the detonation of Jughead. Then she thought of Sawyer and Juliet. And after she, Hurley, Jack and Sawyer had had survived the destruction of Widmore's submarine, she was frantic about Jack, completely ignoring an unconscious Sawyer.

Kate had feelings for Sawyer. I don't doubt that. But I believe that she simply loved Jack more.
posted over a year ago.